Sim Dynasty Message Board - Minors Rankings

	Last active: Never 0 Members Chatting
	Not logged in [Login - Register]

FAQ

Member List $Today\'s Posts$ Today's Posts

My Boards

My Topics

Hot Topics Forum Stats

Stats

Board Rules

RSS Feed

Back to:

Sim Dynasty Message Board » Private Leagues » Bill Lee League » Minors Rankings

Printable Version
Subscribe | Add to Favorites

Aaronfiasc0

Starter

Rating 373
Registered 4-17-2008
Member Is Offline

Mood: Not Set

posted on 4-13-2010 at 02:25 AM

Minors Rankings

Since I had some time, I went through and ranked everyone's minors. I used a 5 point system. I rated them on what the players could become if fully developed. I didn't rank my team because I'd probably be biased. If someone else wants to give it a shot, by all means go ahead.

5 an absolute stud, HOF caliber.
4 a great player, one the best on the team.
3 a useful/serviceable player
2 a line-up filler, not great, not terrible.
1 a useful back up.

The scoring system has its flaws (obviously five 1 point players are not as valuable as one 5 point player. Not to mention its based on my opinions). I think you could argue plus or minus a point on many players.

Nation League

ATL 9 pts

McCormick 1
Larry Gwynn 1
Lonnie Kirsch 2
Gary Jones 1
Jim Bell 4

BKN 13 pts

Perdue 3
Junior Larmore 2
Chris Barron 4
Bob Williams 3
Pete Adams 1

CHN 8 pts

Jermaine Michaels 1
Dane Standkard 1
Clarence Hibbs 1
Ron Nieman 5

CIN 6 pts

Whitey Atkins 2
Bob Johnson 2
Stan Brandt 2

NYN 9 pts

Sam Posedel 2
Lou Appleton 3
Red Lee 1
Bill Ging 3

PIT 10 pts

Joe Blosser 2
Ray Holman 2
Pete Sveum 4
Bill Wathan 2

STL 15 pts

Terry Hankins 4
Bill Thomas 3
Josh McGuire 1
Les Garms 1
Lee Damaska 2
Dick Breeden 1
Hank Kampouris 3

American League

BOS 8 pts

Bruce McKean 4
Harry Bryant 1
Dave Kingmanis 3

DET 4

Greg Branom 4

KC 3

Joe Hassey 1
Bryn Jones 2

NYA 11

Reggie Decker 1
Tom Norman 3 (why is he in the minors?)
Pinky Doby 2
Lou Hoffman 1
Mike Mosser 3
George Ostermueller 1

OAK 10

Red Tettleton 4
Al Brown 4
Vic Macha 2

TB 4

Moose Girardi 2
Johnny Be Good 1
Darrell Sington 1

TEX 6

Joe Fitzberger 3
Augie Lumley 3

WAS 16

Matt Gmur 5
Sherman Mahon 5
Mickey Moore 4
Wes Gowdy 2

boraiders34

All Star

Rating 810
Registered 1-19-2007
Member Is Offline

Mood: Not Set

posted on 4-15-2010 at 02:46 PM

Good analysis. I hope my guys can live up to the hype and help get Washington out of this rut.

RichNYC1

Hall of Famer

Rating 3536
Registered 7-18-2006
Location Medellin, Colombia
Member Is Offline

Mood: pero que bellas paso las horas vaciando botellas y andaleeeeee!!!!!

posted on 4-15-2010 at 03:51 PM

Bob Williams (3) is going to be a monster, cant believe he fell to me at #7

JGL - Brooklyn Trolley Dodgers - 24 Playoffs - 11 WS - 5 Champs

BLL - Brooklyn Superbas - 17 Playoffs - 9 WS - 6 Champs

OCL - Brooklyn Banditos - 8 Playoffs - 4 WS - 1 Champs (Retired)

BRL - Brooklyn Barnstomers- 9 Playoffs - 5 WS (Retired)

DEL - Brooklyn Excelsier Legion - 13 Playoffs - 8 WS - 4 Champs (Retired)

OHL - NYN Gigantes - 4 Playoffs - 2 WS - 1 Champs (Defunct)

SKL - Brooklyn Cyclones - Defunct

CSL - NYN Bowery Boys - Defunct

Me equivoque contigo, como si no supiera, que las mas grandes penas, las debo a mis amores

DW_Geoff

League Commish

Rating 14956
Registered 8-10-2005
Location Montreal, Canada
Member Is Offline

Mood: Always with the negative waves, Bundy, always with the negative waves

posted on 4-15-2010 at 08:33 PM

I think Ging is a lot better than perceived

Tony Gwynn League - Brooklyn Dukes
(Expansion 1960)Playoffs: 1966-1973, 1984-87,League Champs: 1967,69,71-75, 85-87;WS Rings: 1973-74, 85-87

Warren Spahn League - New York Empire
(Expansion 1977):Playoffs: 1983-85,1988-1992,1998,2006-11;League Champs: 1983,84,85,88,89,91,07,09-11;WS Rings: 1989

Oscar Gamble League, yalls league sounds fun - Chicago Kingdom of Steel
(Replacement 1982-)Playoffs: 2001;LCS Winner: ;WS Rings:

Bill Lee League - New York Spacemen
(Founding member)Playoffs: 1953, 1957-1959, 1967-1972,1980-1984League Champs: 1957,1968,1969,1971,1972,1980,1982-1984;WS Rings: 1957, 1968-1969,1982-1984

Gregg Nettles League - Chicago/Milwaukee Czars
(Expansion 1978-1987, Replacement 2004-)]Playoffs: 1986,87;LCS Winner: 1987;WS Rings: 1987

Urban Shocker League - Brooklyn Evil Empire
(Replacement 1972-1994)Playoffs: 1972, 1990-1991League Champs: 1972, 1991, 1993-1994;WS Rings: 1994

Curt Schilling League - Kansas City Wheat Kings
(Replacement 1951-1980)lost ALTB: 1954,65;Playoffs: 1955,62, 64,66-69;78League Champs: 1964,66,67,69;WS Rings: 1964,66,69

Montreal did not fail Major League Baseball, Major League Baseball Failed Montreal

Aaronfiasc0

Starter

Rating 373
Registered 4-17-2008
Member Is Offline

Mood: Not Set

posted on 4-16-2010 at 04:45 AM

Ging hadn't popped his A- in PvR yet. With those type of hitters (D+/B+) its important to know where they are in those grades to be able to judge them. I am interested in seeing how Bob Williams turns out. Guys with splits that big are more prone to be disappointments. Both Ging and Williams could definitely be mashers. I wouldn't argue with increasing them to 4s.

p.s.
My definition of 'useful/serviceable' is closer to 'quality' than 'average'.

RichNYC1

Hall of Famer

Rating 3536
Registered 7-18-2006
Location Medellin, Colombia
Member Is Offline

Mood: pero que bellas paso las horas vaciando botellas y andaleeeeee!!!!!

posted on 4-16-2010 at 02:52 PM

A+ PWR and A+ speed... and Williams is gonna max out both. His D+ health will hurt his overall numbers, but he'll be a .850-.900 OPS guy and run producing machine

boraiders34

All Star

Rating 810
Registered 1-19-2007
Member Is Offline

Mood: Not Set

posted on 4-16-2010 at 05:06 PM

He'll max power and speed but he'll be lucky to break C in contact. I think .850-.900 is out of reach.

Compare to: http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?playername=nobody&mode=stats&id=6650129 and http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?playername=nobody&mode=stats&id=6650218 (slightly lower speed and maybe not 100 in power like Williams will be, but a higher contact than he'll see)

RichNYC1

Hall of Famer

Rating 3536
Registered 7-18-2006
Location Medellin, Colombia
Member Is Offline

Mood: pero que bellas paso las horas vaciando botellas y andaleeeeee!!!!!

posted on 4-16-2010 at 08:45 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by boraiders34
He'll max power and speed but he'll be lucky to break C in contact. I think .850-.900 is out of reach.

He just turned 18 today... Id say its more likely he ends up B/A+ B-/A+.

Contact is very over-rated, yea it cuts down on K's but speed is such a bonus on the BA... we'll know for sure soon enough.

Cboss420

Starter

Rating 274
Registered 1-28-2009
Location Massachusetts
Member Is Offline

Mood: Not Set

posted on 6-19-2010 at 03:28 PM

How's everybody's players doing on this list?

Moose Giradi got a 2

After he read that he was going to be a lineup filler he hit the batting cages and gym hard. Must I say it payed off earning him the ROY award by hitting 20 HR's and knocking in 91 RBI's and swiping 31 SB.

Ken Griffey Jr. Chicago Wind
World Series Champs 1988
Bill Lee League Tampa Bay Cyclones
Joe DiMaggio Kansas City Cycones
World Series Champs 1988
Andre Dawson Tampa Bay Thunder
World Series Champs 2003,2005

DW_Geoff

League Commish

Rating 14956
Registered 8-10-2005
Location Montreal, Canada
Member Is Offline

Mood: Always with the negative waves, Bundy, always with the negative waves

posted on 6-19-2010 at 10:20 PM

Possedal is in Brooklyn, Appleton has been shopped to no avail. Ging will have an opportunity to prove his value

RichNYC1

Hall of Famer

Rating 3536
Registered 7-18-2006
Location Medellin, Colombia
Member Is Offline

Mood: pero que bellas paso las horas vaciando botellas y andaleeeeee!!!!!

posted on 6-20-2010 at 08:12 PM

Williams was .272 BA and .780 OPS in his rookie season (346 AB's.)

Hes gonna be a monster, and Posedel is battler.. if only a 5th SP

boraiders34

All Star

Rating 810
Registered 1-19-2007
Member Is Offline

Mood: Not Set

posted on 6-21-2010 at 06:43 PM

Gmur turned in a fine second season going 14-14 with a 3.83 ERA (and somehow winning a Gold Glove).

Sherm Mahon had a decent rookie campaign, putting up .255/13/84 and tacking on 87 runs and 20 steals.

Moore is in his rookie season now, starting vs. lefties and serving as a utility man vs. rhp. Currently hitting .308 with 1 HR on the short season.

Gowdy didn't manage much and has been relegated to a CP-less minor league roster spot.

DW_Geoff

League Commish

Rating 14956
Registered 8-10-2005
Location Montreal, Canada
Member Is Offline

Mood: Always with the negative waves, Bundy, always with the negative waves

posted on 7-29-2010 at 05:14 PM

Appelton is a valuable bench player

Ging was ROY

sturge

Double A

Rating 30
Registered 6-30-2010
Member Is Offline

Mood: Not Set

posted on 7-29-2010 at 05:55 PM

Pinky Doby 2 (backup)
Lou Hoffman 1 (assumed starting CF) runner up ROY at 31 lol
Mike Mosser 3 (2 time all star in RF)
George Ostermueller 1 (backup)

barrybarrs

All Star

Rating 933
Registered 3-21-2008
Member Is Offline

Mood: go wvu

posted on 8-15-2010 at 08:55 PM

lonnie kirsch is a 4 now lol... the 28 yo 3 rd round pick is leading the n.l. mvp race having hit 24 hrs to back up the 22 he hit last year what a 3rd round pick and with atlanta on the verge of rebuilding he should bring a nice ransom to start the rebuild.......save your chips boys because 3 20 + hr guys in there twenties are going to be available soon including lonnie and jim bell.....also carmen so save your players and picks once this season is over there all available......................................

http://simdynasty.com/ownerteam.jsp?teamid=58968
http://simdynasty.com/ownerteam.jsp?teamid=44820
http://simdynasty.com/ownerteam.jsp?teamid=58536
http://simdynasty.com/ownerteam.jsp?teamid=45160
http://simdynasty.com/ownerteam.jsp?teamid=58992

Overall
Seasons(139)

playoffs (58)

pennants (28)

world champs (14)

barrybarrs

All Star

Rating 933
Registered 3-21-2008
Member Is Offline

Mood: go wvu

posted on 8-15-2010 at 08:57 PM

3RD ROUNDER LONNIE KIRSCH MVP! MVP! MVP!

Sim Dynasty Message Board » Private Leagues » Bill Lee League » Minors Rankings